I loved the premise, and the way we gradually learned more about Peat, Jake, and the situation as the day kept repeating. My heart ached for poor Peat. And Maddie was great. I look forward to reading more by this author.But I struggled frequently to figure out whose head I was in, as the shifts seemed to come at frequent but irregular and unmarked intervals. Usually I read other reviews complaining about head-hopping and think, "Really? Huh. Yeah, I guess so." but I was too caught up in the story to really have noticed (or been bothered) by it at the time. Caught Running and Cut & Run as two popular examples. So I figure if the head-hopping was problematic for me, anyone who was troubled by it in those books might find their head exploding with this one. And yet even with that I loved the book, so I really hope future books will get some better editing.